| Rank | Athlete | Year | Event | Raw | To-Par | Par |
| 1 | Brent Paladino | 2007-08 | 9/10-11 Mid-Pines Intercollegiate | 136 | -8 | 72-72 |
| 2 | Gary Barton | 2004-05 | 3/11-12 Bearkat Classic | 137 | -5 | 71-71 |
| Tim Pemberton | 2001-02 | 4/12-13 Princeton Intercollegiate | 137 | -5 | 71-71 | |
| 4 | Jonas Miller | 2007-08 | 9/21-23 Sea Trail Intercollegiate | 140 | -4 | 72-72 |
| Gary Barton | 2004-05 | 9/27-28 John Dallio Memorial | 140 | -4 | 72-72 | |
| Tim Pemberton | 2004-05 | 9/27-28 John Dallio Memorial | 140 | -4 | 72-72 | |
| Tim Pemberton | 2001-02 | 10/29-30 Charleston Southern | 140 | -4 | 72-72 | |
| Tim Pemberton | 2002-03 | 3/8 Big Red Classic | 140 | -4 | 72-72 | |
| Mark Urbanek | 2000-01 | 9/25-26 Liberty Fall Classic | 140 | -4 | 72-72 | |
| 10 | Brent Paladino | 2007-08 | 9/21-23 Sea Trail Intercollegiate | 141 | -3 | 72-72 |
| Justin Ragognetti | 2001-02 | 3/16-17 El Diablo Intercollegiate | 141 | -3 | 72-72 | |
| Tim Pemberton | 2001-02 | 4/19-21 CAA Championships | 141 | -3 | 72-72 | |
| Doug Hurson | 2005-06 | 10/3-4 Joe Agee Invitational | 141 | -3 | 72-72 | |
| Tim Pemberton | 2004-05 | 10/4-5 Joe Agee Invitational | 141 | -3 | 72-72 | |
| Gary Barton | 2004-05 | 10/4-5 Joe Agee Invitational | 141 | -3 | 72-72 | |
| Billy Musto | 1981-82 | 4/19-20 ODU Seascape | 139 | -3 | 71-71 | |
| Adam Holman | 2001-02 | 3/25-26 W&M Spring | 141 | -3 | 72-72 |