| Rank | Athlete | Year | Event | Raw | To-Par |
| 1 | Gary Barton | 2002-03 | 9/21-22 JMU Fall | 214 | 1 |
| Justin Ragognetti | 2002-03 | 9/21-22 JMU Fall | 214 | 1 | |
| 3 | Gary Barton | 2002-03 | 10/5-6 Wolverine Invitational | 216 | 3 |
| 4 | Gary Barton | 2004-05 | 3/11-12 Bearkat Classic | 217 | 4 |
| Billy Musto | 1982-83 | 5/11-13 Iron Duke | 217 | 4 | |
| 6 | Brent Paladino | 2005-06 | 9/12-13 Cleveland State Invitational | 218 | 5 |
| Billy Musto | 1981-82 | 9/25-27 ETSU | 218 | 5 | |
| 8 | Doug Hurson | 2005-06 | 4/7-8 Marshall Invitational | 219 | 6 |
| Gary Barton | 2004-05 | 4/8-9 Princeton Invitational | 219 | 6 | |
| Tim Pemberton | 2002-03 | 9/21-22 JMU Fall | 219 | 6 | |
| John McHenry | 1985-86 | 3/28-30 Iron Duke | 219 | 6 | |
| John McHenry | 1984-85 | 3/29-31 Iron Duke | 219 | 6 |