| Rank | Athlete | Year | Win |
| 1 | John McHenry | 1982-86 | 5 |
| 2 | Billy Musto | 1979-83 | 2 |
| Gary Barton | 2001-05 | 2 | |
| Mike Gregor | 1981-85 | 2 | |
| Dave Evans | 1975-77 | 2 | |
| Rich Garrison | 1974-78 | 2 | |
| 7 | Tim Pemberton | 2000-05 | 1 |
| Doug Gregor | 1987-91 | 1 | |
| Steve Isaacs | 1967-70 | 1 | |
| John Luczaj | 1992-96 | 1 | |
| Chris Gilmer | 1991-95 | 1 | |
| Gregg Hemphill | 1987-91 | 1 | |
| Justin Ragognetti | 1999-03 | 1 | |
| Erik Nelson | 1985-89 | 1 | |
| Adam Holman | 2001-02 | 1 | |
| Russell Brown | 1971-74 | 1 |