| William and Mary | James Madison | |||
| 1 | Jordyn Moloney | 1 | Natalie Abel | |
| 2 | Anne Dorff | 2 | Danielle Erb | |
| 3 | Lindsey Pflugner | 5 | Jessica Zeroual | |
| 4 | Gina Lang | 6 | Lindsay Callahan | |
| 5 | Katie McCarney | 7 | Megan Weichmann | |
| 6 | Bryana Carey | 8 | Sara Dougherty | |
| 7 | Gabi Smith | 9 | Kelly Turner | |
| 8 | Erin Skipper | 10 | Morgan Maddox | |
| 10 | Lindsay Kresch | 11 | Haley Jacobsen | |
| 11 | Ginny Bray | 12 | Kelly Johnson | |
| 13 | Delaney Gordon | 13 | Meredith Riddell | |
| 17 | Shaylin O'Connell | 14 | Lauren Fanelli | |
| 19 | Cassie Crumal | 15 | Holly Wall | |
| 20 | Brooke Bauernfeind | |||
| 22 | Lauren Powell | |||